Evidence of an accused ictrictyirmct case law database. Requests for amendment of these irs may be made to the rules and procedure committee by a judge, a coinvestigating judge, a coprosecutor, the head of. Ntanda nsereko, rules of procedure and evidence of the. Nevertheless, the two tribunals differ in their relative success in administering justice for crimes. The federal rules of evidence are amended to include an amendment to rule 807. Icty and ictr cases progressed over two decades, forensic anthropology techniques. Rule 2 definitions a in the rules, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean. In all cases, the rules of procedure and evidence should be read in conjunction with and subject to the provisions of the statute.
Similarly, the icty and ictr have largely avoided common law rules of evidence. Article 282 of the statute mandates the judges to adopt the rpe and, in doing so, to be guided by the lebanese code of criminal procedure lccp and other reference materials reflecting the highest. A person against whom one or more counts in an indictment. Legacy website of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda. September 2011 monthly forecast security council report. Statute of the international tribunal for rwanda icls. Criminal tribunal for rwanda, rule 101, july 5, 1995, as amended hereinafter ictr rules. The foregoing amendment to the federal rules of evidence shall take effect on december 1, 2019, and shall govern in all proceedings thereafter commenced and, insofar as. Punishment for violations of international criminal law. Widespread and systematic rape pervaded both the genocides in bosniaherzegovina in 1992 and in rwanda in 1994.
Entry into force these rules of procedure and evidence, adopted pursuant to article 14 of the statute of the tribunal, shall come into force on 29 june 1995. The detention facility of the residual special court shall include all premises where suspects or accused, or convicted persons are detained in accordance with these rules and with the rules of detention. International criminal law, international criminal procedure, retrial, expedience, fair trial, right to a speedy trial, international criminal court, international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia, international criminal tribunal for rwanda, special court for sierra leone, icc, icty, ictr. The rules of procedure and evidence of the international criminal. Rules of procedure and evidence global policy forum. Rules of evidence in cases of sexual assault rule 97.
Urukiko mpanabyaha mpuzamahanga rwashyiriweho u rwanda was an international court established in november 1994 by the united nations security council in resolution 955 in order to judge people responsible for the rwandan genocide and other serious violations of. After 10 years of practice, the question arises as to how the ictr has acquitted itself of this important task set out in the statute and, subsequently, the rules of procedure and evidence. The tribunal is governed by the statute annexed to security council resolution 955 and by the rules of procedure and evidence of the tribunal the rules8. This chapter further deals with witnesses, their oral or written testimony, as well as the special rules that apply to expert witnesses. There are no uniform rules of procedure and evidence in international criminal. Nevertheless, the ictr s office of the prosecutor otp requested that the accused be provisionally detained under rule 40 provisional measures of the ictr rules of procedure and evidence rpe8 only two days later. Chamber ii of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda the tribunal, composed of judge arlette ramaroson, presiding, judge william h.
Definitions a in the rules, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean. Requests for amendment of these irs may be made to the rules and procedure committee by a judge, a coinvestigating judge, a coprosecutor, the head of the defence support section. Digital evidence and war crimes prosecutions flash. Comparing the rules of evidence applicable before the icty.
State authorities are often more inclined to cooperate with the prosecution rather than the defence when gathering evidence. Rules of procedure and evidence of the residual special court for sierra leone 7 detention facility. Pdf safeguarding the rights of suspects and accused persons in. This major reference work identifies and crystallizes the common rules and principles underlying international criminal procedure, as developed by international courts and tribunals since the. Therefore, to ensure that both parties stand on an equal footing in the preparation and the presentation of its cases, the ictr must constantly reevaluate its rules of. These rules of procedure and evidence, adopted pursuant to article 15 of the statute of the tribunal, shall come into force on 14 march 1994. Mutual disclosure, unilateral disclosure and nondisclosure under the rules of procedure and evidence 305 renee pruitt 25. Rules of evidence and procedure for the international. Rule 42 ictr rules of procedure and evidence furthermore. International criminal tribunal for rwanda, rules of.
A person indicted by the icty, the ictr, or the mechanism in accordance with article 1 of the statute. All three processes are examples of the liberalprosecution model, i. Considering the provisions of the statute of the tribunal the statute and the rules of procedure and evidence the rules. At any stage of the procedure, the international tribunal for rwanda may formally request national courts to defer to its competence in accordance with the present statute and the rules of procedure and evidence of the international tribunal for rwanda. According to resolution 1966, the rules of procedure and evidence are to take effect upon adoption by the judges of the mechanism unless the council decides otherwise.
Three transitional justice processes, namely the international criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr, the national genocide trials ngts and gacaca courts, have been instituted to deal with the issues of justice and reconciliation in postgenocide rwanda. Rules of procedure and evidence of the ictr deepdyve. In response to these conflicts, the yugoslav tribunal icty and the rwandan tribunal ictr were created and charged with meting justice for crimes committed, including rape. Key issues an immediate issue for the council to address is the appointment and length of term of the ictr prosecutor. In the ictr for example, many defendants would prefer a european prison not only. The international criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr. The elaboration of principled and practical rules of evidence and procedure the rules is critical to the functioning of the international criminal court icc. The act of taking a suspect or an accused into custody. The reaction of a commonlaw commentator to this rule was quite predictable, it is hoped that this provision will not be interpreted as a license for judges to descend pellmell into the area of trial combat. Statute of the international tribunal for rwanda as. The tribunal is governed by the statute annexed to security council resolution 955 and by the rules of procedure and evidence of the tribunal the rules 8. The judges of the international tribunal shall adopt rules of procedure and evidence for the conduct of the pretrial phase of the proceedings, trials and appeals, the admission of evidence, the protection of victims and witnesses and other appropriate matters. It covers the essential procedural and evidentiary aspects of trials before the icc from the beginning of an investigation until the sentence, including appeals, revision, and enforcement of the sentence.
Ictr rules of procedure and evidence rpe reflects this model and provides that evidence will be presented in the following sequence. The appeals chamber in katanga and chui ruled that rule 814 of the rules of procedure and evidence should be read to include the words persons at risk on account of the activities of the court so as to reflect the intention of the states that adopted the rome statute and the rules of procedure and evidence, as expressed in article 543f. Rules of procedure and evidence international criminal court. Article 282 of the statute mandates the judges to adopt the rpe and, in doing so, to be guided by the lebanese code of criminal procedure lccp. Pdf the international criminal tribunal for rwanda researchgate.
Resolution 29 2000 30 november 2000 deciding that two additional ictr judges will be elected, who will sit in. International criminal court, rules of procedure and evidence, rule 71. The trial proceedings of the international criminal court. A case concerning maritime delimitation and territorial questions between qatar and bahrain introduction in july of 1991, the nation of qatar filed an application beginning proceedings in the court against bahrain with respect to disputes between the two states. Essays on icty procedure and evidence in honour of. Case law of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda. These rules of procedure and evidence, adopted pursuant to article 28 of the statute of the special tribunal for lebanon, shall enter into force on 20 march 2009. Pdf this essay will appear as the ninth chapter of the rules, practice, and jurisprudence of international. The historical record in international criminal law and plea. Hearsay evidence 291 almiro rodrigues and cecile tournaye 24. Resolution 1165 1998 30 april 1998 establishing a third trial chamber and amends articles 10, 11 and 12 of the ictr statute. The rules of procedure and evidence of the international criminal court do not affect the procedural rules for any national court or legal system for the purpose of national.
International criminal tribunal for rwanda wikipedia. Rwanda may formally request national courts to defer to its competence in accordance with the present statute and the rules of procedure and evidence of the international. A in these rules of procedure and evidence, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean. The rules of procedure and evidence are reproduced from the official records of the assembly of states parties to the rome statute of the international. Rules of procedure and evidence a m ended on 7 m arch 2003 amended on 1 august 2003 a m ended on 30 o ctober 2003 amended on 14 march 2004 a m ended on 29 m ay 2004 a m ended on 14 m ay 2005 a m ended on m ay 2006 a m ended on 24 n ovem ber 2006 a m ended on 14 m ay 2007 a m ended on 19 n ovem ber 2007. Sep 01, 2005 after 10 years of practice, the question arises as to how the ictr has acquitted itself of this important task set out in the statute and, subsequently, the rules of procedure and evidence.
Irs shall be submitted to the rules and procedure committee as soon as possible. Proof beyond a reasonable doubt is required by the international criminal court, the international criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr, and the international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia icty rome statute, art. Rules of procedure and evidence of the international tribunal. Rules of procedure and evidence of the residual special court for sierra leone. Therefore, to ensure that both parties stand on an equal footing in the preparation and the presentation of its cases, the ictr must constantly reevaluate its rules of procedure and evidence. Establishing the international criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr and attaches its statute.
Definitions amended 29 may 2004 a in the rules, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean. This is the first publication on the trial proceedings of the international criminal court, the icty and the ictr collected in one volume. See rules of procedure and evidence of the international. Aug 31, 2011 according to resolution 1966, the rules of procedure and evidence are to take effect upon adoption by the judges of the mechanism unless the council decides otherwise. Records of the assembly of states parties to the rome statute of the international. The rules of procedure and evidence rpe or rules must be based on and consistent with the statute of the tribunal. International criminal tribunal for rwanda, rules of procedure and evidence, u. Procedural due process and the prosecution of genocide. Ictr rules 1995 rules of procedure and evidence of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda. The disclosure of exculpatory material by the prosecution to the defence under rule 68 of the icty rules 315 mark b. These rules of procedure and evidence as first amended on 7 march 2003, are applicable pursuant to article 14 of the statute of the special court for sierra leone, and entered into force on 12 april 2002. The decision by the united nations international criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr not to transfer four of its remaining cases to the rwandan domestic courts is consistent with the ictr s focus on the development of international criminal law.
669 185 1079 991 860 25 864 807 1132 405 1497 1078 1484 512 102 44 219 1130 1312 842 1398 553 147 1055 932 767 618 40 1384 779 1022 701 1114 1390 156 625 604 502 1351 574 107 771